At the age of 50, it’s time to ask yourself what is probably the most important financial question of your life: would you prefer to draw your retirement assets as a pension or as a lump sum? This decision has a massive impact on your financial future and your lifestyle in retirement. Learn about the pros and cons of the two options – and how to make the choice that really suits you.

Why is the decision “pension or lump sum” so important?

Your pension assets are designed to enable you to lead a fulfilling, financially self-determined life. Sound good? It is. The question of “pension or lump sum” is central here – because once you have made it, you cannot undo your choice.  Therefore, the following applies: the sooner you address the issue, the better you will be able to strategically plan and shape your retirement provisions.

Pension: focus on security

Guaranteed lifelong income and pensions for surviving dependants – that’s what a monthly retirement pension offers. If you opt for a pension, your pension assets will be paid out every month and, after your death, your spouse and children will receive annuity payments, depending on your age.  Are you unfamiliar with financial topics? No problem. After all, by choosing a pension, you don’t have to worry about managing your pension fund assets – the pension fund will continue to do that for you.  

Payouts in the form of an annuity, however, must also be fully taxed as income. And: the amount of your money you actually receive is determined by the pension fund’s conversion rate – over which you have no influence.  

Who is a pension suitable for? Primarily for people who value security and predictability, have little interest in financial assets, want a stable, reliable source of income and expect to have a long life ahead of them. 

Lump-sum payment: flexibility and personal responsibility

A one-off lump-sum payment gives you a lot of freedom: you receive your entire capital paid out and can do whatever you want with it. After your death, you can simply bequeath the remaining money along with your other assets.    

To ensure that your capital lasts for the rest of your life, you should invest it profitably and securely. Because even if you retire at 65, you still have several decades of life ahead of you at best – and you should be able to enjoy them to the fullest extent and without financial worries. 

If you don’t have any special knowledge of or interest in financial topics, you should take advantage of professional financial planning and asset management. Then experts will take care of investing your money in such a way that you can only sit back and relax.  

Who is a lump sum suitable for? A lump-sum payment can be a good option for individuals who want to take active care of their finances, value greater flexibility and are prepared to accept the investment risk in order to benefit from potentially higher returns. 

Tip: A payout can be particularly worthwhile in the case of large pension fund assets. After all, with the right investment strategy, your capital will be able to generate sufficient returns to ensure a regular income.

Pension or lump sum: an overview of the pros and cons

 PensionLump sum
Advantages
  • Regular monthly income
    • Guaranteed, lifelong payments
      • Your pension fund takes care of investing your money
        • Spouses/cohabiting partners (depending on pension fund) receive a pension until they die
          • Children receive children’s benefits  
          • Maximum flexibility: your money is freely available
            • Any remaining capital can be bequeathed after death
              • Higher return opportunities, depending on the investment strategy
                • One-off taxation at a reduced rate
                  • Income tax after withdrawal only on securities income and dividends

                  Disadvantages 

                  • Pension is fully taxed as income
                    • Reduces flexibility
                      • The spouse’s pension only amounts to a percentage (depending on the pension fund) of the retirement pension
                        • After death, dependants are often not entitled to payment of the remaining lump sum (except for spouse’s pension)  
                        • No guarantee that the capital will last for the rest of your life
                        • Requires strategic, goal-oriented wealth management
                          • A high degree of personal responsibility
                            • After the withdrawal, the entire capital is taxed as wealth  

                            Make the most important financial decision of your life with the help of experts

                            Our financial advisers not only know what matters when deciding between an annuity and a lump sum, but also provide you with comprehensive advice on which option suits you best. So why make such a far-reaching decision on your own when you can get expert help?

                            Combination: the best of both worlds?

                            A combination of a pension and a lump-sum payment is also possible. Then you benefit from both the security of an annuity and the flexibility of the lump-sum payment. If you use some of your capital to make major purchases or fulfil a long-cherished dream, invest some of the capital profitably and draw the rest as a pension to cover your running costs.  

                            The optimal allocation of your lump sum and pension depends on your needs and financial goals. The split is best determined in the context of an individual financial plan. 

                            Seven questions to reach the right decision

                            Before deciding on an option or seeking financial advice, you should answer these seven questions:  

                            1. How important is financial security to me? 
                            2. How well do I know about finance and investment?
                            3. Do I plan to spend more in the initial phase after retirement?
                            4. What is my life expectancy and my state of health? 
                            5. What is my overall financial situation – including other assets? 
                            6. What is my partner’s financial situation? 
                            7. What conditions does my pension fund offer?

                            The answers to these questions indicate that you will tend to make the decision that is right for your financial situation, your plans, goals and dreams, as well as for your security needs – people who value security and predictability more than potential returns, for example, are usually better off with a pension. Your decision also depends on your personal pension situation and, not least, on the conditions of your pension fund. You can see the conditions of your pension fund in your pension certificate. A financial advisor can provide you with additional help with your decision.

                            Your investment strategy will then ensure that your capital lasts for a lifetime

                            Whether you opt for a full or partial lump-sum withdrawal: to ensure that your money lasts for the rest of your life, you need a long-term, diversified and risk-optimised investment strategy – just like Swiss pension funds:

                            • Broad diversification: investments in different asset classes, such as equities, bonds, real estate and alternative investments reduce risks.
                            • Long-term planning: strategic investing without short-term emotions or hectic reallocations.
                            • Strict risk management: guaranteed by proven principles and regulation.
                            • Goal-based investing: your investment strategy is based on your individual life situation and goals.

                            Expert tip: Infrastructure investments offer an attractive risk-return profile and are increasingly also accessible to private investors – an opportunity for inflation protection and stable returns.

                            Make an informed decision – one that will last

                            Your financial future will therefore be determined by this one choice – “pension or lump sum”. Precisely because it has such far-reaching consequences, you shouldn’t just consider it superficially and just before you retire. After all, you benefit most when you know exactly what you want – and how to achieve your goal of a relaxed, financially secure retirement in the easiest and most secure way.  We will be pleased to support you.

                            Rick Naef

                            Rick Näf

                            Wealth Planner

                            Rick Näf is a Wealth Planner at Swiss Life Wealth Managers in Winterthur. He has been working in direct contact with clients at Swiss Life for four years, offering comprehensive advice in the areas of asset management and financial planning. Thanks to his qualifications as a Federal Financial Planner and a Certified Financial Planner, his clients benefit from sound and holistic support, with a personal approach always at the heart of his service.